Thought of Crumpet's

Worldbuilding Loops

A repost of my Agora writing thread post

Question: How do you do worldbuilding loops without your writing efforts turning into an infinite loop of make believe setting development?

Answer: The below is what I do. I add to this blog the admonition that you only need 'enough' worldbuilding to not have unknown questions on your mind. If you know how many bags of rice are in that particular shop stall, and why, great. But if you know who put them in that bag and their family lineage back 100 years, too much detail! When in doubt, put 6 months of focused worldbuilding in your novel and then call it good enough, adding only surgically needed new details to maintain your story consistency.

Kallisto said: Kind of a question, technically. I'd prefer to frame it as asking for your personal experiences with writing and world building in general.

I am (or well, have been for about 13 months at the time of this post) writing/creating a series, my first ever foray into writing proper outside of a some tiny Zine stuff. How do you properly do your world building? Without falling into an eternal rabbit hole of fleshing out the world, and never getting around to actually writing actual stories, be it short stories, or full novels and anything in between.

I realized I've spent most of the last year just doing character designs, book covers, plots outlines, and deep world lore, but have only managed to spit out 1 1/2 chapters for the first Novel I intend to make, followed by a massive detour into a short story set within the world - which I have been making decent progress on, but it feels like I am spending too much time on these extra things (despite immensely enjoying it) and not the mainline series I want to make.

Would love to hear your though process when it comes to these weird kind of loops(?)

And my reply:

Setting by Jack Bickham does address this, though I enjoyed playing out the world building checklist in Kobold Guide to World building volume 1. Volume 2 was much less valuable to me.

The goal I try to use these days is called the Y cubed law, which I combine with a Microscope (it's a book) style high level history and a top level world definition to give myself the entire sandbox then zoom way in to where my story is happening, and go build the facades and sets around it.

  1. Setting concept brainstorming (One method is described below)
  2. Setting history using Microscope
  3. Setting Bible created through Kobold Guide to Worldbuilding part 1
  4. Setting descriptions tied into my manuscript copy using Setting book and the Y cubed Law

Brainstorming your setting concept.

So, pick the standard setting stereotype for your genre. Say medieval European standard tolkienesque setting as a starting point.

Now, come up with the top 10 points that define that setting for you as a reader. Here's mine for the thought experiment.

  1. Low technology
  2. Magic exists
  3. There are non human sentient races
  4. Human cultures are pre industrial and thus easily digested
  5. Wars and conflicts are always somewhere, at least in mind if not body
  6. Feudal or at least class based society
  7. Monsters and mythical creautes are around and possibly following us
  8. Farms, everywhere
  9. There are various religions and at least one of them is a stereotypical Catholic church ripoff
  10. There is one continent that represents the known world

So, your list will probably be different. Now pick 8 of those 10 things you listed and drop 2 things. So let's say we kill off the church and farms, our world will need religion work and a way for society to feed itself.

So you dream up a top level explanation for what was missing so you are back to 10 points.

So we add some giant pitcher plants that produce a nutritional sap for food, and have a religion around them, worshipping the trackers who can find these elusive and short lived plants each year season after season.

And then with the remaining list, we further twist two or more items to be different from the standard fantasy setting list (TV Tropes has a page on that setting, if you need more ideas).

So let's twist the mythical creatures are around and the feudal society rules. There are what we'd call mythical creatures around, they are let's say treefolk, and they are the feudal overlords for most humans. But they are themselves serfs to the wyrms, who themselves are vassals to titans.

So humanity is in a standard fantasy world, except they have a hard time growing population because food is scarce, and they keep getting made to do the dirty and hard work their treefolk overlords send them on, and the treefolk themselves have cruel masters who drive the normally contemplating creatures to self interested cruelty.

Then the Microscope, Setting, and Kobold Guide to Worldbuilding volume 1 books come into play to take this high level concept design and give it some general meat on, respectively, history, geographic / architectural, and political / cultural / arcane details for the general ballpark of your story.

Then you can either adjust your story concept to make it fit its new stage better, or you can take a finished story draft and adapt it to the stage in revisions or by plugging in specific hints and details to give that sense of versimilitude to the story, grounding it in the stage using tools like the Y Cubed Law to connect the story's now moments to the history and background of the setting stage, without info dumping all over the reader.

This is all dashed off in a rush so happy to elucidate more as needed.